NRI

Google fb32x32 twitter linkedin feed-icon-32x32

Film Review: Saving Face

Film Review: Saving Face

May 30, 2012
Pulkit Datta

The Oscar-winning documentary on acid attacks in Pakistan is a difficult, but incredibly powerful experience.



There are some films that evoke an inexplicable mix of anger, pain and inspiration all at the same time. Saving Face, directed by Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy and Daniel Junge, is one such film, telling the harrowing story of the victims of acid attacks in Pakistan. Winner of the Academy Award for Best Documentary Short and recently screened at the New York Indian Film Festival, Saving Face follows the stories of two women - Zakia and Rukhsana - that try to rebuild their lives with physical and emotional scars in a society that barely punishes the perpetrators of the acid attack.

The directors don't shy away from showing the full extent of the damage caused by the attacks on these women. For Zakia, her hobby of being photographed in new clothes was ended abruptly when her husband threw battery acid on her face. The result - the entire left side of her face is completely shapeless, as if it just melted away. Her nose is disfigured and the left side of her lips are being pulled upwards as the scar tissue tightens, making it difficult for her to eat or speak.

Rukhsana, an otherwise spirited young woman, bears the equally horrific scars of her acid attack. It ruined the lower half of her face as well as her neck, as she laments the day she married her husband. Rukhsana's husband threw acid on her, while her sister-in-law poured gasoline and her mother-in-law lit the matchstick. While the women are locked in legal battles with the men that attacked them, in a judicial system that doesn't have a clear law in place for such crimes, they also try to overcome the painful process of emotional healing and a severe loss of self-confidence.

Zakia wraps herself up completely every time she steps out of her home, using her burqa as a shield more than anything else. Large black sunglasses then cover her eyes, as she tries her best to be completely hidden from public view, the loss of self-confidence crippling her in many ways. Thus we see the first layer of 'saving face', a constant effort by the women to literally hide their faces from a society that is both unwilling to punish the assailants and is also unprepared to see the consequences of the acid attacks.

Meanwhile, their husbands outright deny their crime and in turn blame the women for what happened. One husband's father even adds sarcastically, "Women are doing a lot of 'great' things these days, such as cutting our noses." Obaid-Chinoy and Junge are careful not to show the husbands in a judgmental light. Instead, they allow the men to say what they want and let the viewer make the verdict instead. It's not a surprise whose side you will take, but it is a storytelling technique that successfully enrages you, making you want to to do something to help these women fight for justice.

Luckily, this is where the second layer of 'saving face' comes in, as the women's path soon crosses with charitable work of London-based, Pakistani-born plastic surgeon Dr. Mohammed Jawad. Dr. Jawad visits the Burns Center in Islamabad every few months, and offers the women reconstructive surgery. It's a chance to literally save their face.

As Dr. Jawad works with Zakia and Rukhsana on their individual reconstructive surgeries, he realizes that his biggest challenge is "to manage expectations". But he isn't alone in the efforts to help these women move on. Obaid-Chinoy and Junge also follow parliamentarians that are pushing a bill that calls for severe punishment for those convicted of such attacks. It is passed unanimously. There is also a support group that brings victims of acid attacks together to share their stories and find strength in each other.

Saving Face is a difficult film to watch, because it confronts you so vividly with a major problem, and a horrific one, that exists in our world. It's not just about Pakistan, but about the struggle to end violence against women in every part of the world. Obaid-Chinoy and Junge present the stories of Zakia and Rukhsana not in a depressing or demoralizing light, but celebrate the small steps these women take to regain control of their lives. Some unsung heroes, like Dr. Jawad and the parliamentarians, are also worth highlighting. In that way, the film is inspiring. But the statistic opening the film explains that each year, over 100 women are victims of acid attacks. And for that reason, there is still plenty of work to be done. 

3 Comments

  • Manoj
    By
    Manoj
    09.07.14 07:27 PM
    Chinoy has done such a wonderful job of hihltigghing the tragedy of acid attack victims. Too often society often questions what the women have done to deserve such a fate when the question should be, What is being done to stop this undeserved violence upon women.Unfortunately, one victim not featured in this Oscar-winning film by the name of Fakhra Younus, committed suicide on March 17, 2012. Her story and plight were similar to other victims in that Pakistan is a patriarchal society in which men commit such horrific acts of violence and yet, due to wealth or family connections, escape any type of justice.Farhana, this is why this site is so important to women everywhere, to give a voice to those who cannot speak for themselves and to give those of us who enjoy freedom and individual rights the capability to spread the message and lend our voices to those who need it most. Thank you for that.
  • Pulkit
    By
    Pulkit
    31.05.12 07:21 AM
    @Harry, thanks for the comment, and for raising so many complicated questions. :-) The easiest one to answer is about when the film is out. As far as I know, the film is available on HBO, but that might be restricted to the US market. You can get more info on the film here: http://savingfacefilm.com/

    Also, I don't think violence against women are restricted to only Muslim countries. India, for one, has a big problem in this regard. Just the issue of dowry is in fact a form of violence against women, and often leads to horrible incidents of violence. That is just one example. Also, violence against women arises from the presumption in numerous societies in the world that men are more powerful than women. Such perceived dominance leads to such violence.

    Finally, as for your question about religion - All I will say is that yes, religion has always played a big part in the course of history. But whether it has done more harm than good, I'll choose to stay out of that discussion for now. A convenient "no comment", if you will. :-)
  • HARRY
    By
    HARRY
    30.05.12 11:42 PM
    @ Pulkit

    This is one of the sad story I first read in the newspaper, regarding these women. I do want to watch this, when it's out. When is it out? Pulkit.

    The one thing I want to say is, isn't this mostly common in all the muslim countries, where there are more crimes against women and freedom. I may sound a racist and a bigot, which I'm not, but this is only an observation over time on what I've read and seen on TV.

    The other thing I want to ask you is, would you not say, that religion has done more harm, then good to human race?
    You are probably wondering, why have I asked such a question. Well, Since dawn of time, man has murdered another in the name of religion and justified it well.

    Few weeks ago I was watching a film called Apocalypto by Mel Gibson on mayan culture, which demonstrates that people will do anything for personal gain, and their ego, and the religion always plays big part in people's behaviour in general.

    HARRY

Leave a comment